Confessions of a Confessor

– 1,200 words | 6 min. average read

The older I get, the more I wonder how often courage feels like anything special while you’re exercising it. It may feel no more heroic than writing a sentence you’d prefer to keep to yourself and then deciding to let it stand.

I know some people will judge me for what I’m about to say. Some may be people I’ve known and loved for years.

I’ve asked myself what good could come of laying the journey of my soul open to public scrutiny. Then I think of someone else wrestling with an angel in the dark, wondering if anybody they know has ever had the same fight.

For that person, I’m now willing to speak.

After 60+ years in the Christian community, I no longer identify with the religion and instead embrace the pre-Antiochian nomenclature of “believer.” I’ve reached back for the simpler word because it more honestly describes my current profession.

More closely aligned to the experience of Abraham than the Epistles of Paul, I find that I’m out of harmony with a few of Christianity’s pillars of belief. Maybe I should say, America’s version of Christianity, a concise evangelical, Protestant formulation.

Perhaps too simply listed for some, those pillars are, 1) Biblical inerrancy, 2) the divinity of Jesus, 3) his physical resurrection and 4) the atonement through Christ. Of the four, the first two are the foundation upon which the last two are built.

This is where the courage part comes in. My experience no longer embraces a few of those religious imperatives.

Biblical Inerrancy.

I accept the Bible as one of the books through which God reveals himself to his creation, teaching us how to live honorably in this world and how to obtain access to the next. A combination of revelation and myth, the Bible itself makes no claims that embracing scriptural inerrancy is a requirement for fellowship with the Almighty.

Biblical inerrancy was heavily formulated in the late 19th century by Princeton scholars such as A.A. Hodge and B.B. Warfield as a reaction to the rise of higher biblical criticism, the Enlightenment and scientific challenges to literal historical readings.

So, as far as the first “Pillar” is concerned, the earth was not created in six days. A universal flood did not cover the entire earth to the tops of the highest mountains. Joshua did not stop the sun in the sky for 24 hours. My trust in God’s existence and compassion survives the thought that the sun went down at its usual time on the day Joshua fought.

While I strongly believe in a God of miracles, intervening to heal, to guide, to comfort and instruct, some of the biblical claims belong in what I’m tempted to call, The Book of Whoppers. While teaching me invaluable lessons on life and faith, none of those “miracles” are necessary for trusting in a compassionate, involved deity. A story can give me something to live by even when I doubt that it happened as told.

Which brings me to the second Pillar.

The Deity of Christ.

By 325 A.D., the church was beginning to fracture from the theological schism inherent in the controversy formalized by Arius and Athanasius of Alexandria: was Jesus Christ fully God or was he a being created by God?

Constantine insisted on a standardized and unified codification of the Christian religion for his empire and called for The Council at Nicaea. The council of priests decided that a “Trinity” was an acceptable solution for the problem.

But Monotheism is not naturally suited to a plurality in the Godhead. It’s incongruent with the Shema, “Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one.”

The Council had no choice. Without a Trinity, “God in three persons,” Jesus could not be divine. And the entire religion stood on that principle. The Nicene Creed marked a defining moment when Christian theological beliefs were formalized through an assembly of bishops convened by imperial authority.

The enduring irony is that a creed intended to unify Christianity became a defining boundary between accepted orthodoxy and heresy, contributing to centuries of theological conflict over precisely who Jesus was and what Christians were required to believe.

I do not need for Jesus to be divine. It’s sufficient that he was the door, the bridge to connect me with the Father. I do not pray to Jesus. I pray to God “my Father” just like Jesus taught us. Jesus of Nazareth is my brother, my teacher and exemplar. He is the way by which I came to knowledge of the Father.

If the most significant ministry of Jesus is to “turn the hearts of the children to the father,” that goal is accomplished in my life and my fellowship does not depend on the deity of Jesus. The work of the Atonement, making “at one again,” remains a functioning grace in my life.

But, as far as the physical resurrection of Jesus is concerned, the Jury is still out. I am, therefore, by religious definition, more Jewish than Christian and heretic to a significant percentage of American Christians.

So be it.

When God called Abraham to leave his country and his father’s household, Abraham had no tradition through which to understand what was happening to him. Judaism, Christianity and Islam would all look back to him, but he enjoyed no such benefit. The law of Moses, the Qur’an and Bible lay far in the future. The faiths that would tell his story could offer him no guidance as he lived it.

Abraham grew up in a world with its own gods, customs and obligations. He knew what it meant to belong to a household and what it would cost to leave one. But there was no rule for what to do when the God who spoke to him asked him to leave the country he knew for a land he would be shown. Though the future remained hidden, the command was clear enough to act on.

Without a religion, a Bible or a Sunday School teacher to guide him, Abraham yet became “the Friend of God.”

How is that possible?

Micah sheds light on such a walk with the Lord. He ponders the question, “What does God require of us?”

Is it the surrender to the notion of biblical inerrancy? Is it embracing the whole of the New Testament accounts concerning Jesus of Nazareth? Is it fasting, prayer and religious obligations?

Joe Markko, author, musician and founder of Home Before Midnight Publishing

“Do justice, love mercy and walk humbly with your God.” The verbs matter. We do justice when fairness costs us something. We love mercy when we are willing to extend it to someone who needs it as badly as we do. We walk humbly when we let God correct us and take the next faithful step even when we cannot see where the road leads.

When we get to Heaven, we’re all going to change our minds about a few things. Until then, perhaps we can love one another enough to make a difference in the way we treat those who know we’re wrong.

See you at the Throne.


HOME BEFORE MIDNIGHT, LLC | PUBLISHING
Cleveland, Ohio

Books · Articles and Essays · Music and Lyrics · Contact

© 2026 Home Before Midnight, LLC / Joe Markko. All rights reserved.