1,400 words | average read, 7 min.
As confounded as I have been by the entirety of Donald Trump’s presidency, the part I have the hardest time understanding begins in the pews.
I can understand why Christians would vote for a candidate who promises to advance policies they believe in. What I cannot understand is watching people who once insisted that character mattered in public office rise, again and again, to defend conduct they would condemn in almost anyone else.
What did I miss? I don’t get it.
Political loyalty is understandable. Differences over public policy are inevitable. But when loyalty becomes unconditional, when wrongdoing is excused because it serves a preferred political outcome, we have crossed a line that ought to trouble every thinking American.
Donald Trump has been convicted of 34 felonies involving falsified business records. Six of his businesses have filed for bankruptcy. Numerous ventures bearing his name have failed or disappeared. He has been divorced twice and impeached twice. A civil jury found him liable for sexually abusing and defaming E. Jean Carroll.
These are matters of public record not partisan inventions.
And these offenses scarcely begin to address the far more consequential issues surrounding his efforts to overturn the 2020 presidential election, his treatment of constitutional restraints and the increasingly troubling relationship between presidential power, personal enrichment and political retribution.
Perhaps his greatest offense against the American experience has been the dividing and poisoning of our culture: the deliberate cultivation of distrust, the normalization of falsehood and the suggestion that loyalty to one man should take precedence over loyalty to the Constitution.
Trump’s political behavior bears the unmistakable influence of his former mentor, Roy Cohn, whose combative philosophy treated intimidation, accusation and relentless counterattack as substitutes for integrity. It is a philosophy well suited to a bully but poorly suited to the leadership of a constitutional republic.
History offers abundant warnings about what happens when personal power becomes more important than public responsibility. The catastrophic abuse of entire nations has occurred under monarchies, colonial governments, fascist regimes, communist states and military dictatorships alike.
Ideological labels have varied, but the mechanisms by which leaders acquire, concentrate and abuse power are disturbingly familiar. Consider Kim Il Sung, Idi Amin, Saddam Hussein, Pol Pot, Mao Zedong, Joseph Stalin, Adolf Hitler, and Augusto Pinochet.
While their ideologies, circumstances and crimes differed enormously, and the Trump administration cannot be equated with their atrocities, they have all employed the same, dark machinations.
The study of authoritarianism in the lives of those leaders reveals recurring warning signs that Americans would be foolish to ignore. The mechanisms that provided absolute power to monsters are becoming institutionalized in our own government.
- Concentration of power: The purposeful weakening of legislatures, courts, elections and independent institutions that restrain executive authority.
- Elimination of opposition: Portraying political disagreement as disloyalty, subversion or treason.
- Dehumanization: Turning ethnic, religious, immigrant or political communities into convenient enemies.
- Control of information: Discrediting independent journalism while elevating propaganda and manufactured narratives.
- Institutionalized intimidation: Employing the machinery of government to threaten, punish or silence perceived adversaries.
- Absence of accountability: Protecting loyalists from consequences while demanding punishment for opponents.
These are not exclusively the instruments of the political right or left. They are the familiar tools of authoritarian power, wherever it appears, and should serve as unmistakable warnings to thinking Americans as we approach 2027.
All of this brings me back to the question raised at the beginning: How have so many Bible-believing Christians become the most enthusiastic defenders of a man whose conduct they would condemn in almost anyone else?
Confounding, to be certain, but it’s not entirely new territory:
“Give us Barabbas!”
I cannot escape the uncomfortable parallel. With much of the evangelical community providing the vanguard, Americans chose a convicted, unrepentant, vulgar criminal to lead our nation.
A political champion whose defining public characteristics seem far closer to aggression, vengeance and self-exaltation than to the teachings of Jesus. And many who once spoke most loudly about righteousness, character and the moral responsibilities of public office have become his most determined apologists.
What changed? Was it the teaching of Jesus or merely the political usefulness of those teachings?
Jesus himself offered a straightforward means of recognizing the character of a person: “By their fruits you shall know them.” By that standard, I see little in Donald Trump’s public conduct that resembles the character Christians are instructed to emulate.
Waving a Bible before television cameras, invoking the name of God at political rallies and occasionally scattering a few crumbs of recognition toward religious audiences do not constitute Christian character.
Of course, I acknowledge the clear fact that the president’s constitutional responsibility is not to advance Christianity. It is to uphold the Constitution and serve the American people, regardless of their religious convictions. That last distinction seems conveniently lost among Christians who have confused political access with spiritual victory.
Meanwhile, America’s longstanding international relationships have suffered under an administration that repeatedly treats alliances as transactions and diplomatic commitments as bargaining chips.
Our allies are left wondering whether American promises will survive a change in presidential mood, whether agreements will be honored and whether the United States remains a dependable partner. Trust, painstakingly built over generations, is being destroyed with remarkable speed. Once squandered, trust cannot simply be summoned back with another presidential proclamation.
Casting blame on previous presidents, “Dumocratic” opponents, the news media, federal judges, state governments and institutions within the federal government itself, Donald Trump owns none of the problems created by his unique will.
“It’s everybody’s fault but mine.”
The prophet Nathan confronted the political leadership of his day, King David, with a story about a wealthy man who steals the only lamb belonging to a poor neighbor.
David is outraged. He demands judgment against the offender.
Then Nathan delivers four words that strip away every pretense of royal innocence. All excuses are gone, there is no one else to blame, the weight falls full:
“Thou art the man.”
It is among the most powerful confrontations in biblical literature. A prophet stands before a king and refuses to excuse wrongdoing merely because the offender possesses extraordinary power.
Nathan does not flatter David. He does not calculate the political consequences of speaking the truth. He does not suggest that the king’s achievements somehow cancel his transgressions.
He holds him accountable.
That is the prophetic tradition I remember. And it is precisely what seems missing from much of contemporary American Christianity.
Where are the Nathans? Where are the religious leaders willing to stand before political power and say, without qualification, that wrongdoing remains wrongdoing even when committed by someone who promises to advance their interests?
What happened to the conviction that truth is not negotiable, morality is not partisan and the teachings of our holy books are not subject to revision whenever an election approaches?
Initially, I imagined The Church was being temporarily deceived. But the most unyielding thoughts, the ones that troubled me most, had to do with the possibility that the American church has not been deceived at all.
Perhaps many have simply decided that access to earthly power is worth more than fidelity to heavenly principles. And, if that is true, the betrayal is not merely political. It is spiritual. When faith becomes the servant of power the world does not become a better place. It becomes a more dangerous place.
Perhaps that is the final irony of the present moment. Christians professing absolute confidence in God’s sovereignty who also seem convinced that their faith, their country and even civilization itself can survive only through the political fortunes of one, deeply flawed man.
If the scriptures mean what they say, then their conviction is not an expression of faith. It’s a confession of how little faith remains.

The question is not whether Donald Trump can save Christianity or America. The question is whether American Christianity can recover its moral authority after surrendering so much of it to Donald Trump.
In 2022, Elizabeth Bangs adapted a proverb to describe what happens when spectacle takes possession of public office. “When a clown moves into a palace, he does not become a king. The palace becomes a circus.”
Somewhere beyond the lights of the newly-gilded Presidential Big Top, in the deafening silence between the pulpit and the Corrupted Throne, Nathan’s accusation still waits to be heard.
The longer I listen for it, the less certain I am that he is speaking to the man in the palace alone.
HOME BEFORE MIDNIGHT, LLC | PUBLISHING
Cleveland, Ohio
Books · Articles and Essays · Music and Lyrics · Contact
© 2026 Home Before Midnight, LLC / Joe Markko. All rights reserved.




